How do you calculate SAIDI? SAIFI, CAIDI and MAIFI explained with a worked example
A step-by-step guide to SAIDI, SAIFI, CAIDI and MAIFI under IEEE 1366: formulas, which interruptions count, major event days and a fully worked example.
A 2012 profile of EGAT's Wang Noi gas-fired combined-cycle plant in Ayutthaya, Thailand: its three original blocks, the Block 4 expansion then under construction, and what became of it.
In August 2012, the Wang Noi power plant was one of the pillars of Thailand’s electricity system. Owned and operated by the state utility, the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT), it is a natural-gas-fired combined-cycle station in Wang Noi district, Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya province, about 70 km north of Bangkok. At the time it had three combined-cycle blocks with a total capacity of a little over 2,000 MW, and a fourth block was under construction.
Wang Noi was conceived in the early 1990s as an urgent project to meet fast-growing demand from the industrial estates of Thailand’s lower central region. The Thai cabinet approved Blocks 1–3 in 1993–94. Power Technology records that the original plan for four 300 MW trains was revised to three larger blocks, partly for economic reasons and partly because of the difficulty of moving heavy equipment to an inland site.
Each of the original blocks follows the same “2-on-1” arrangement:
Mitsubishi Heavy Industries supplied the main gas and steam turbine equipment, with Black & Veatch providing engineering services. The first gas turbines came on line at the end of 1996, the steam turbines followed through 1997, and the third block’s steam turbine was completed in April 1998. EGAT gives 28 April 1998 as the completion date for Blocks 1–3. Power Technology put the investment in the first three blocks at about US$1.5 billion. In 1999 Wang Noi became the first Thai power plant certified to the ISO 14001 environmental management standard.
Natural gas is the main fuel, with diesel oil held as a back-up. Gas reaches the plant from two directions: from the Gulf of Thailand via a pipeline from Bang Pakong, and from Myanmar’s offshore fields via a 154 km pipeline from Ratchaburi, completed in 2000. Dual supply matters for a plant of this size: losing a single pipeline would otherwise remove a large block of generation from the grid at once.
In February 2011 the cabinet approved a fourth block under Thailand’s Power Development Plan 2010, on the existing site. Construction began in December 2011. Block 4 was built by a Siemens and Marubeni consortium around two Siemens SGT5-4000F gas turbines and one Siemens steam turbine, a single large block with a quoted efficiency above 57%. EGAT gives its contracted capacity as 750 MW.
In 2012 EGAT also completed an inlet-air cooling system on Block 3, which it said could add around 70 MW at high ambient temperatures. The reason is basic gas turbine physics. A turbine is a constant-volume machine: it swallows roughly the same volume of air each second, so its output depends on the air’s density. Density is inversely proportional to absolute temperature:
ISO rating condition: 15 °C = 288 K
Typical hot afternoon in central Thailand: 35 °C = 308 K
Density ratio = 288 / 308 ≈ 0.935
At 35 °C the turbine passes about 6.5% less air by mass than at its rating point, and its output and efficiency fall accordingly, just when air-conditioning demand peaks. Chilling the intake air recovers much of that lost output at a fraction of the cost of new capacity.
For engineers in Malaysia, Wang Noi illustrated where Sabah’s own gas-fired programme was heading: large, efficient combined-cycle blocks on a secure gas supply. In 2012 Sabah was building its first major combined-cycle station, the 300 MW Kimanis plant, at roughly a seventh of Wang Noi’s size. In the same year, Malaysia’s TNB was bidding for a large coal-fired plant in Bangladesh, showing how differently the region’s utilities were choosing fuels. The plant also sits in Ayutthaya province, which was among the areas hardest hit by Thailand’s severe floods in late 2011, when several industrial estates were inundated, a reminder that siting and flood defences are part of generation reliability (see our explainer on measuring supply reliability).