Calculating power factor from electricity meter readings (kWh and kVARh)
How to work out average power factor from kWh and kVARh meter readings, why Malaysian utilities surcharge low power factor, and how to size correction capacitors.
Power factor is the ratio of real power, which does useful work, to apparent power, which the supply network must actually carry. A site with a low power factor draws more current than it needs for the same kilowatts, so Malaysian utilities have long set a minimum and added a surcharge to the bill when a customer falls below it. The good news is that the monthly average power factor can be worked out from two numbers already on the bill: the kWh and kVARh readings. This guide shows the method, the surcharge rules as they stood in 2013, and how to size capacitors to correct the problem.
The power triangle
For a sinusoidal supply, the three quantities form a right-angled triangle:
Real powerP in kW (energy: kWh)
Reactive powerQ in kvar (energy: kVARh), produced by motors, transformers, fluorescent ballasts and other inductive loads
Apparent powerS in kVA, where S = √(P² + Q²)
Power factor is PF = P / S = cos φ, where φ is the angle between P and S.
Figure: Adding capacitors (Qc) shortens the reactive side, reducing apparent power and current for the same real power.
Average power factor from meter readings
Most commercial and industrial meters record both active energy (kWh) and reactive energy (kVARh). Over a billing period:
PF(avg) = kWh / √(kWh² + kVARh²)
This is an energy-weighted average for the month. It is not the same as an instantaneous reading on a panel meter, which changes from minute to minute with the load. Utilities use the energy-based figure for billing because it is what the revenue meters record.
Worked example (illustrative)
A medium-voltage commercial customer’s meter shows, for one month:
The ratio kVARh/kWh = 0.75 is also tan φ, which is useful later for capacitor sizing.
Why utilities penalise low power factor
A low power factor makes the network carry current that delivers no energy. At a fixed voltage, current is proportional to kVA, so cables, transformers and switchgear must be sized for the larger kVA, and the resistive losses (proportional to current squared) rise. In the example above the network carries 25% more current than it would at unity power factor.
Malaysian surcharge rules in the original era
Tariff conditions of the period, at both TNB and SESB, required customers taking supply below 132 kV to maintain a power factor of at least 0.85; TNB set 0.90 for supply at 132 kV and above. The surcharge for supply below 132 kV was a percentage of that month’s bill:
Between 0.85 and 0.75 lagging: 1.5% for each 0.01 below 0.85.
Below 0.75 lagging: the 15% for the band from 0.85 to 0.75, plus 3% for each 0.01 below 0.75.
TNB’s current published conditions keep the same thresholds and the same 1.5% and 3% steps, applied to the energy, demand and fuel-adjustment components of the bill. The surcharge applies to commercial and industrial accounts; domestic tariffs are billed on kWh alone.
Surcharge in the worked example
Assume the customer is on TNB’s Tariff C1 (medium-voltage general commercial) as published from 1 June 2011: RM25.90 per kW of maximum demand and 31.2 sen per kWh. With an assumed maximum demand of 200 kW:
Item
Calculation
RM
Energy charge
48,000 kWh × RM0.312
14,976.00
Maximum demand charge
200 kW × RM25.90
5,180.00
Bill before surcharge
20,156.00
PF surcharge
(0.85 − 0.80) / 0.01 = 5 steps × 1.5% = 7.5%
1,511.70
Total
21,667.70
Had the average fallen to 0.70, the surcharge would be 10 × 1.5% + 5 × 3% = 30% of the bill.
Sizing power factor correction capacitors
The reactive power a capacitor bank must supply to move from PF1 to PF2 at real power P is:
Qc = P × (tan φ1 − tan φ2), where φ = arccos(PF)
Continuing the example, at the 200 kW demand and a target of 0.95:
tan φ1 = 0.75 (PF 0.80)
tan φ2 = tan(arccos 0.95) = 0.329
Qc = 200 × (0.75 − 0.329) = 84.3 kvar
A practical choice would be a 90 kvar automatic bank in steps, so the controller can follow the load. Correcting only to the 0.85 limit would leave no margin, while correcting to about 0.95 typically clears the surcharge with room for load variation.
Effect on current (415 V, three-phase):
Before: S = 200 / 0.80 = 250 kVA → I = 250,000 / (√3 × 415) = 348 A
After: S = 200 / 0.95 = 211 kVA → I = 210,526 / (√3 × 415) = 293 A
Loss ratio = (293 / 348)² ≈ 0.71, i.e. about 29% lower I²R losses upstream
Capacitance per phase for a delta-connected 90 kvar bank (30 kvar per phase) at 415 V, 50 Hz:
C = Q / (2πf × V²) = 30,000 / (2π × 50 × 415²) ≈ 554 µF per phase
Practical cautions
Harmonics. Variable speed drives, UPS systems and LED drivers inject harmonic currents. Capacitors lower the network’s resonant frequency and can amplify harmonics; detuned banks with series reactors are normally specified where drives are present.
Avoid over-correction. A leading power factor at light load can raise voltage. Automatic stepped banks switch capacitors in and out with the load.
Correct close to the load where possible. Large motors can be individually compensated; this also reduces current in the final circuits, not just at the intake.
Specify to standard. Low-voltage shunt capacitors are covered by IEC 60831; check voltage rating, temperature class and discharge resistors.
Domestic customers
Households in Malaysia are billed on kWh only, so improving power factor at home does not reduce the bill. This is the physics behind warnings about plug-in energy saving devices, which rely on small capacitors. To estimate what a home actually uses, see what is your household electricity use?.
What has changed since
TNB’s published thresholds (0.85 below 132 kV, 0.90 at 132 kV and above) and surcharge steps remain the same as described above. Tariff rates themselves have changed several times since 2013, beginning with the January 2014 tariff increase, so the ringgit figures in the worked example are historical. Smart meters now let large customers view kWh and kVARh profiles at short intervals, which makes it easier to see when power factor drops and to size correction accordingly.
IEC 60831-1: Shunt power capacitors of the self-healing type for a.c. systems having a rated voltage up to and including 1 000 V, International Electrotechnical Commission
In October 2012 Malaysia's energy ministry restated its plan to end incandescent lamp sales by 2014. The schedule, the savings claim, and the power factor and mercury questions.
How to estimate a household's monthly kWh from appliance ratings and hours of use, check it against the bill, and price it with Malaysia's 2012 domestic tariff blocks.
In April 2012 Malaysia's Energy Commission warned against plug-in energy saving devices. The physics: homes pay for kWh, and a capacitor at the socket does not reduce kWh.