The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

Malaysia to ban incandescent bulbs by 2014: the phase-out, its rationale and its critics

In October 2012 Malaysia's energy ministry restated its plan to end incandescent lamp sales by 2014. The schedule, the savings claim, and the power factor and mercury questions.

Line illustration for Engineering

In mid-October 2012, Malaysian newspapers reported that the Ministry of Energy, Green Technology and Water (KeTTHA) was phasing out traditional incandescent light bulbs, leading to a complete ban in 2014. The policy was not new: it had first been announced in March 2010. But the renewed coverage prompted a fair question from consumers and engineers alike: was two years enough time, and were the replacements ready?

The policy and its timetable

On 18 March 2010, the then Energy, Green Technology and Water Minister, Datuk Seri Peter Chin, announced that incandescent lamps would be replaced by energy-efficient alternatives in stages over three years, with their sale stopped in 2014. He presented the move as part of Malaysia’s commitment to reduce the carbon intensity of its economy by 40% by 2020, and estimated that consumers would save about RM336 million a year.

The Energy Commission (Suruhanjaya Tenaga) described the schedule to industry in two phases:

Phase Period Lamps affected
1 January to December 2011 Incandescent lamps of 100 W and above
2 January 2012 to December 2013 All other incandescent lamp types
End point 2014 No incandescent lamps for general lighting on sale

The replacements named by the ministry were compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs), T5 fluorescent tubes and LED lamps. The electrical industry association TEEAM supported the aim but asked for a gradual approach, enough lead time for manufacturers and importers, and better price and reliability of the efficient lamps.

Why target the filament lamp

An incandescent lamp heats a tungsten filament until it glows. Most of the input becomes heat rather than visible light: the US Department of Energy put a typical 60 W lamp at about 15 lumens per watt in 2012, against roughly 60 lm/W for a CFL and 90 lm/W or more for the best LED lamps. In a hot climate the waste heat also adds to air-conditioning load. The detailed comparison is in our article on LED lighting in 2012.

Worked example (illustrative tariff). A household replaces six 60 W bulbs with 13 W CFLs, each used five hours a day:

Saving per lamp = (60 − 13) W × 5 h × 365 = 85.8 kWh/year
Six lamps       = 6 × 85.8 ≈ 515 kWh/year
At an assumed 30 sen/kWh ≈ RM154 a year

Even if each CFL cost several times as much as a filament bulb, the electricity saved would repay the difference within months at this usage. To check your own numbers, see what is your household electricity use?

The objections, examined

Up-front cost

This was the strongest objection in 2012. A filament bulb cost very little, while branded CFLs cost many times more and LED lamps more again. The lifetime saving was real, but low-income households pay the up-front price, not the lifetime cost. The DOE’s figures show LED lamp prices falling steeply during 2011, which suggested the gap would narrow, but in late 2012 it had not yet closed.

Power factor

Many CFLs and LED lamps use a simple rectifier-and-capacitor input stage that draws current in short peaks. Their power factor, the ratio of real power (W) to apparent power (VA), is therefore well below the unity of a resistive filament, mainly because of harmonic distortion rather than phase shift. The concern was that millions of such lamps would trouble the utilities.

The arithmetic eases most of that worry. Because the efficient lamp draws so much less power, its apparent power is still lower than that of the bulb it replaces:

60 W filament at PF 1.0       → 60 / 1.0  = 60 VA
13 W CFL at an assumed PF 0.55 → 13 / 0.55 ≈ 24 VA

The current on the circuit falls by more than half. The genuine issue is harmonic current, which adds up in neutral conductors of three-phase distribution, and the answer is a standard for lamp harmonics rather than retaining filament lamps. Malaysian domestic customers were not billed for power factor; TNB’s power factor penalty applied to industrial and commercial customers below 0.85. Our guide to calculating power factor from meter readings explains the quantities involved.

Mercury

CFLs and fluorescent tubes contain a small dose of mercury, which is released if the lamp breaks or is landfilled. Under the EU’s RoHS rules, which set the benchmark manufacturers worked to, a CFL below 30 W was limited to 3.5 mg of mercury during 2012 and 2.5 mg from 2013. The quantity is small per lamp but significant in aggregate, so collection and recycling of spent lamps matter. Mercury-free LEDs were the cleaner long-term answer.

Quality

Early CFLs had slow warm-up, a cold colour and shorter lives than claimed, and cheap imports varied widely. Mandatory performance standards were the obvious remedy, and they arrived the following year.

What has changed since

On 3 May 2013, the Electricity (Amendment) Regulations 2013 came into force, introducing Minimum Energy Performance Standards (MEPS) for five domestic products: air conditioners, refrigerators, televisions, domestic fans and lamps. Lamps sold in Malaysia now had to meet minimum efficiency requirements, which reinforced the phase-out with an enforceable standard rather than a ministerial announcement.

The bigger change was technological. LED lamp prices fell so far over the following decade that CFLs themselves became the lamp being displaced. Internationally, parties to the Minamata Convention on Mercury agreed to phase out CFLs for general lighting by 2025 and all general-purpose fluorescent lamps by the end of 2027. The 2012 critics were right that the replacements were not yet cheap or perfect; the ban’s supporters were right that the direction was settled. Lumens, not watts, are now the measure to shop by, as explained in what determines the brightness of an energy-saving lamp.

Sources and further reading

  1. Govt to replace all bulbs with energy-efficient ones by 2014 (18 March 2010), The Star, via Green Building Index archive
  2. Courtesy visit to Energy Commission (incandescent phase-out schedule), The Electrical and Electronics Association of Malaysia (TEEAM)
  3. Electricity (Amendment) Regulations 2013, P.U.(A) 151, Energy Commission of Malaysia
  4. Electricity (Amendment) Regulations 2013, International Energy Agency policy database
  5. Directive 2011/65/EU (RoHS), Annex III, as in force January 2014, legislation.gov.uk (EU retained text)