The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

What determines the brightness of an energy-saving lamp? Lumens, watts and efficacy

Why lumens, not watts, measure lamp brightness; luminous efficacy of incandescent, CFL and LED lamps as of 2012; colour temperature; and how to choose a replacement.

Line illustration for Engineering

For a century, people chose light bulbs by watts: a 60 W bulb was “normal”, 100 W was “bright”. That habit made sense when nearly every household lamp was an incandescent filament, because their light output per watt was broadly similar. In 2012, as Malaysia prepared to phase out incandescent lamps and shops filled with compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) and early LED lamps, the habit stopped working. This article explains what actually determines a lamp’s brightness and how to compare lamps of different technologies.

Lumens measure light; watts measure electricity

  • Luminous flux, in lumens (lm), is the total visible light a lamp emits in all directions, weighted for the sensitivity of the human eye. This is the number that corresponds to “brightness” when comparing lamps.
  • Power, in watts (W), is the electrical input. It determines running cost, not light output.
  • Luminous efficacy, in lumens per watt (lm/W), links the two: Efficacy = lumens / watts.
  • Illuminance, in lux (lx = lm/m²), is the light arriving on a surface such as a desk. It depends on the lamp’s lumens, the fitting, the room and the distance.

So for any lamp: Light output (lm) = Efficacy (lm/W) × Power (W). Within one technology, more watts means more light. Between technologies, efficacy differs by a factor of several.

How a CFL makes light, and what sets its output

A CFL is a folded fluorescent tube with its own electronic ballast in the base. The ballast starts the lamp and drives a high-frequency current through a low-pressure mercury vapour. Excited mercury atoms emit mainly ultraviolet radiation, which a phosphor coating inside the glass converts into visible light. The light output of a given CFL is set by:

  • Arc power, controlled by the ballast design; this is why CFL lumens scale with rated watts.
  • Tube length and phosphor area, which is why higher-wattage CFLs are physically larger.
  • Phosphor blend, which trades efficacy against colour quality.
  • Temperature. Fluorescent output depends on mercury vapour pressure, so CFLs take time to reach full brightness and can lose output in enclosed, hot fittings or when very cold.
  • Age. Phosphor degradation reduces output over life; rated lumens are for a new lamp.

An incandescent lamp, by contrast, heats a tungsten filament until it glows. Most of the energy leaves as infrared heat, which is why its efficacy is low.

How the technologies compared in 2012

The US Department of Energy summarised typical luminous efficacy ranges, including ballast and driver losses, as follows (LED values as of spring 2009, when the fact sheet was published):

Light source Typical efficacy (lm/W)
Incandescent 10 to 18
Halogen 15 to 20
Compact fluorescent (incl. ballast) 35 to 60
Linear fluorescent (incl. ballast) 50 to 100
Cool white LED, above 4,000 K (incl. driver) 60 to 92
Warm white LED, below 4,000 K (incl. driver) 27 to 54

The same fact sheet noted that warm white LEDs were improving fast, approaching CFL efficacy, with leading products reaching a colour rendering index of 80.

To stop misleading packaging, the European Union’s household lamp regulation of 2009 set the minimum lumens a lamp must emit before it can claim to be “equivalent” to a given incandescent wattage. Three of its reference points:

Claimed incandescent equivalent Minimum lumens (CFL) Minimum lumens (LED and other)
40 W 432 lm 470 lm
60 W 741 lm 806 lm
100 W 1,398 lm 1,521 lm

Using these figures, a 60 W incandescent lamp delivers roughly 741 / 60 ≈ 12 lm/W, consistent with the DOE range. A CFL at an assumed 55 lm/W needs about 741 / 55 ≈ 13.5 W for the same light; an LED at an assumed 70 lm/W needs about 806 / 70 ≈ 11.5 W. This is why “13 W CFL replaces 60 W” was a common claim in 2012.

Colour temperature and colour rendering

Two lamps with the same lumens can look quite different:

  • Correlated colour temperature (CCT), in kelvin. Lower values (about 2,700 to 3,000 K, “warm white”) look yellowish like incandescent light; higher values (about 4,000 K “cool white”, and around 6,500 K “daylight”) look whiter or bluish. Cooler light can appear brighter to many people even at equal lumens, so compare like with like.
  • Colour rendering index (CRI, Ra). How faithfully colours appear compared with a reference source. Incandescent lamps score close to 100; good CFLs and LEDs of the period around 80.

Worked example: how many lumens does a room need?

A simple lumen-method estimate (illustrative values):

Room: 3 m × 4 m = 12 m²
Target illuminance (assumed for general living space): 150 lux
Utilisation factor (light reaching the working plane): 0.5
Maintenance factor (dirt and lamp ageing): 0.8

Lumens required = E × A / (UF × MF) = 150 × 12 / (0.5 × 0.8) = 4,500 lm

That is about six lamps of 741 lm (60 W incandescent equivalent). At 4 hours a day for 30 days:

Option (per lamp) Power kWh per month (each) Cost per month (each) at 21.8 sen/kWh
60 W incandescent 60 W 7.2 RM1.57
13 W CFL 13 W 1.56 RM0.34
10 W LED (illustrative) 10 W 1.2 RM0.26

The 21.8 sen/kWh rate is TNB’s 2012 domestic lifeline rate; households using more than 200 kWh a month pay higher marginal rates, so their savings are larger.

Choosing a replacement

  1. Read the lumens, not the watts, and match or exceed the old lamp’s light output.
  2. Pick the colour temperature for the room: warm white for living and sleeping areas, cooler white for kitchens and work areas.
  3. Check the fitting. Enclosed or recessed fittings run hot; choose lamps rated for them. Use dimmable lamps only with compatible dimmers.
  4. Check the cap type (for example E27 screw or B22 bayonet) and the physical size.
  5. Consider directionality. For downlights, a directional LED can deliver more useful light than a higher-lumen omnidirectional lamp.

Related reading: government to ban incandescent bulbs, LED lighting: the future and what is your household electricity use?.

What has changed since

LED lamps have overtaken CFLs on efficacy, life and instant full brightness, and have become the default replacement lamp. The DOE fact sheet quoted above set a long-term research goal of 160 lm/W for cost-effective white LED systems by 2025. Regulation followed the technology: in 2022 the US Department of Energy codified a minimum efficacy of 45 lm/W for general service lamps, a level above the efficacy range of incandescent and halogen lamps in the DOE table above, and the EU replaced its 2009 lamp regulation with a new ecodesign regulation for light sources (Regulation 2019/2020). The principle in this article is unchanged: compare lamps by lumens, then choose the lowest watts that deliver them with the colour quality you want.

Sources and further reading

  1. Energy Efficiency of White LEDs (PNNL-SA-50462, June 2009), U.S. Department of Energy, Building Technologies Program
  2. Commission Regulation (EC) No 244/2009, Annex II (equivalence claims for non-directional household lamps), European Commission / legislation.gov.uk
  3. Energy Conservation Program: general service lamps 45 lm/W backstop (Federal Register, 9 May 2022), U.S. Department of Energy
  4. Government to replace all bulbs with energy efficient ones by 2014 (The Star, 19 March 2010), The Star (via Green Building Index)
  5. Electricity Tariff Schedule effective 1 June 2011 (Tariff A, domestic), Tenaga Nasional Berhad