The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

LED lighting: why it looked like the future in 2012, and what still held it back

Efficacy, lifetime, price and light quality of LED lighting in 2012, using US Department of Energy data, with the colour, heat and cost caveats buyers faced at the time.

Line illustration for Engineering

By August 2012, light-emitting diodes had moved from indicator lamps and torches into street lights, downlights and retail displays, and governments, including Malaysia’s, were planning to move away from incandescent bulbs. The case for LEDs rested on three numbers: how much light they produce per watt, how long they last, and how fast their price was falling. In 2012 the first two were already impressive; the third was the main obstacle.

How an LED makes white light

An LED is a semiconductor junction that emits light when current flows through it. A single junction emits a narrow band of colour, so almost all white LEDs in 2012 used a blue gallium-nitride chip coated with a yellow phosphor; the mix of transmitted blue and re-emitted yellow is seen as white. Adding red-emitting phosphor gives a warmer colour and better colour rendering, at some cost in efficiency.

One popular description of LEDs as “cold light” needs correcting. LEDs emit almost no infrared in the beam, so the illuminated object is not heated, but a large share of the electrical input still becomes heat at the chip. That heat has to be conducted away through the lamp body and heat sink, which is why thermal design dominates LED engineering.

Efficacy: light per watt

Efficacy is the light output divided by the electrical input:

Efficacy (lm/W) = luminous flux (lm) / input power (W)

The US Department of Energy’s April 2012 solid-state lighting plan tabulated typical products of the time:

Light source (2012) Efficacy Output Power CRI Rated life
Incandescent 15 lm/W 890 lm 60 W 100 1,000 h
Halogen 22 lm/W 1,100 lm 50 W 100 5,000 h
Compact fluorescent 63 lm/W 950 lm 15 W 82 12,000 h
LED A19 lamp (L Prize winner) 93 lm/W 910 lm 9.3 W 93 25,000 h
Linear fluorescent, lamp and ballast 108 lm/W 6,100 lm 56 W 85 25,000 h
LED 2 ft × 4 ft troffer 110 lm/W 4,000 lm 36 W 90 75,000 h

The DOE noted that typical LED replacement lamps achieved around 70 lm/W, with the best, such as the L Prize lamp, reaching 90 to 100 lm/W. Commercial LED packages, the bare light-emitting components, had reached 144 lm/W for cool white and 111 lm/W for warm white. In other words, LEDs had decisively beaten incandescent and compact fluorescent lamps but were only level with a good linear fluorescent system.

Bar chart of 2012 efficacy: incandescent 15, halogen 22, CFL 63, LED A19 lamp 93, linear fluorescent system 108, LED troffer 110 lumens per watt IncandescentHalogenCFLLED A19 lampFluorescent tube systemLED troffer 15226393108110 lm/W
Figure: Efficacy of typical light sources in 2012, from the US DOE Multi-Year Program Plan (April 2012), Table 3.1.

What the efficacy gap means in energy

Worked example. A lamp providing about 900 lm, used four hours a day:

  • 60 W incandescent: 60 × 4 × 365 = 87.6 kWh a year
  • 15 W compact fluorescent: 15 × 4 × 365 = 21.9 kWh a year
  • 9.3 W LED: 9.3 × 4 × 365 ≈ 13.6 kWh a year

Replacing the incandescent lamp saves about 74 kWh a year; replacing the CFL saves about 8 kWh. That second figure explains why, in 2012, LEDs were an obvious upgrade from filament lamps but a harder sell against CFLs. For a household view of these numbers, see what is your household electricity use?

Lifetime: what “50,000 hours” means

LED lifetime is not the point at which the lamp goes dark. It is normally quoted as L70: the operating hours until light output falls to 70% of its initial value. Packages tested at controlled temperature were rated around 50,000 hours, but a complete lamp is limited by its hottest and weakest parts, usually the driver electronics and the phosphor at high temperature, which is why the DOE listed 25,000 hours for the L Prize lamp. The L Prize test required lumen maintenance above 70% at 25,000 hours; the winning Philips lamp was projected to exceed 99%.

Price: the real barrier

The DOE reported that the typical US retail price of a 60 W-equivalent LED lamp fell from about US$40 to US$25 during 2011, and that warm-white lamps were selling at around US$16 for 400 lm and US$24 for 800 lm, roughly US$30 per thousand lumens. A 13 W CFL cost about US$2 per thousand lumens. At component level, cool-white LED packages had fallen to about US$8 per thousand lumens and warm-white to about US$12. The DOE expected further cuts in 2012, and its long-term target for packages was US$0.50 per thousand lumens at 266 lm/W.

Light quality: colour, rendering and heat

  • Colour temperature (CCT). Measured in kelvin; around 2,700–3,000 K looks warm like an incandescent lamp, 4,000 K neutral, 5,000 K and above cool. Early LEDs were most efficient at cool colour temperatures, which many people found harsh indoors.
  • Colour rendering index (CRI). A 0–100 scale comparing how a source renders a set of test colours against a reference source of the same colour temperature. Incandescent lamps score 100 by definition. Cheap LEDs of the period often sat around 70, with weak rendering of saturated reds; the L Prize lamp reached 93.
  • Thermal management. Light output, efficiency and lifetime all fall as junction temperature rises. A lamp in an enclosed fitting in a hot ceiling space can perform well below its datasheet. This matters in tropical buildings.
  • Brightness labelling. Lumens, not watts, describe brightness. Our explainer on what determines the brightness of an energy-saving lamp covers this in detail.

Two claims worth correcting

Fluorescent lamps do contain mercury, but in milligram quantities: under EU rules in force from 2013, a compact fluorescent lamp below 30 W was limited to 2.5 mg and a standard T8 tube to 3.5 mg. That remains a disposal problem, but not “huge amounts”. And LEDs do waste energy as heat; they simply waste much less than a filament.

What has changed since

The DOE’s expectations proved conservative. LED lamp prices fell far below the 2012 levels, efficacy of mainstream products passed that of fluorescent systems, and LEDs became the default for new lighting in homes, offices and streets, including Malaysia’s large-scale street-lighting conversions later in the decade. Policy followed: Malaysia’s incandescent phase-out and, globally, the Minamata Convention’s decisions to phase out compact fluorescent lamps by 2025 and general-purpose fluorescent lamps by the end of 2027. The question of whether LEDs could replace fluorescent tubes is taken up in can we replace all fluorescent bulbs with LEDs? The quality issues described above, colour rendering, heat and driver reliability, are still the points that separate good products from poor ones.

Sources and further reading

  1. Solid-State Lighting Research and Development: Multi-Year Program Plan (April 2012), US Department of Energy
  2. L Prize 60W Replacement Competition, US Department of Energy
  3. Department of Energy announce Philips as winner of L Prize competition (3 August 2011), Philips (now Signify)
  4. Directive 2011/65/EU (RoHS), Annex III, as in force January 2014, legislation.gov.uk (EU retained text)