The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

Germany to continue residential battery storage subsidies: the KfW programme 275 reversal

In late 2015 Germany reversed a decision to end KfW programme 275, its subsidy for home batteries paired with solar PV. How the scheme worked, why it was saved, and the 2016 terms.

Line illustration for Renewable Energy

At the end of 2015, Germany’s home battery industry was spared a sudden stop. In early November the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy had confirmed that the KfW subsidy for battery storage paired with small solar PV systems, known as programme 275, would end on 31 December 2015. Within weeks the decision was reversed, and by late December the government had committed to a successor programme starting as early as possible in 2016. The episode showed how much the young home-storage market still depended on public support.

The programme as it stood

The storage programme was launched on 1 May 2013, funded by the federal government and administered by KfW, the state-owned development bank. It combined two forms of support for households installing a stationary battery with a PV system of up to 30 kWp:

  • A low-interest KfW loan covering the PV system and battery, or the battery alone when added to an existing PV system.
  • A repayment bonus (Tilgungszuschuss), a grant that reduced the loan to be repaid, of up to 30% of the eligible battery costs. It was capped at €600 per kWp of PV capacity for new systems and €660 per kWp for batteries retrofitted to existing systems.

In return, the system had to limit its feed-in to the grid to 60% of the PV array’s rated output, for the life of the installation. The aim was to reduce midday feed-in peaks on the low-voltage network and to drive down battery costs by building a market.

Worked example. A household installing a 5 kWp PV array with a new battery in 2015:

Maximum repayment bonus = 5 kWp × €600/kWp = €3,000
                          (and no more than 30% of eligible battery cost)
Maximum feed-in         = 60% × 5 kW = 3 kW

On a sunny day the array might produce close to 5 kW at noon, but only 3 kW could be exported; the battery and household loads had to absorb the rest.

The market it built

The programme coincided with rapid growth. Market researchers EuPD Research estimated that about 5,000 solar-plus-storage systems were installed in Germany in 2013, about 9,000 in 2014 and 15,000 to 16,000 in 2015. By November 2015, 13,600 storage systems had received funding under the programme, and battery prices were falling: pv magazine reported falls over the previous twelve months of 11% for stationary lead-acid batteries and 18% for lithium-ion. For context on the global PV market behind this growth, see global solar PV market hit a cumulative milestone.

Why the ministry wanted to end it

On 6 November 2015 the ministry confirmed to pv magazine that the programme would close at the end of the year because its objective, cutting storage costs, had been achieved. It did so despite a recommendation from its scientific monitor, RWTH Aachen, to extend the scheme with minor technical changes. The solar industry association BSW-Solar had called for a three-year extension. EuPD Research calculated that the end of funding would cut the market’s growth to 13% in 2016.

The reversal

About two weeks after the announcement, at the 16th Forum Solarpraxis in Berlin, a ministry official said the parliamentary budget committee was discussing an extension and that three more years appeared likely. On 18 December 2015, replying to a question from Green Party politician Oliver Krischer, the government confirmed that a new programme would be designed on the basis of the old one’s results, would start “as early as possible in 2016” and was expected to run until 2018. Exact conditions were to follow.

Several arguments carried the day. Feed-in tariffs for new small PV systems had fallen below household electricity prices, so storing solar power for self-consumption had become the main economic case for many new solar buyers, and losing the storage subsidy risked slowing PV uptake as well. The industry also argued that distributed batteries, in aggregate, could become a meaningful flexibility resource for the grid.

What has changed since

The new programme was announced in February 2016 and opened to applications on 1 March 2016, with about €30 million from the economics ministry for the period to the end of 2018. The ministry reported that the first round had supported about 19,000 systems and around €450 million of investment. The new terms were less generous and tightened the grid condition:

Condition 2013–2015 From March 2016
Repayment bonus Up to 30% of eligible battery cost 25% until June 2016, 22% in the second half of 2016, then stepping down to 10% by the end of 2018
Cap per kWp of PV €600 (new), €660 (retrofit) €500, no distinction between new and retrofit
Maximum feed-in 60% of PV rated output 50% of PV rated output

For the same 5 kWp system, the maximum grant fell to 5 × €500 = €2,500 and the export limit to 2.5 kW. Demand still exceeded expectations: the federal funds for 2016 were almost exhausted by the end of September, and KfW stopped new commitments in early October 2016.

The subsidy did what it was designed to do. Home batteries became a standard companion to new rooftop PV in Germany, and the federal programme was allowed to expire at the end of 2018. Malaysia, which was itself reshaping its solar policy at the time, as described in Malaysia to install 1,250 MW of solar PV, had no comparable residential storage incentive at the time; the economics of self-consumption there are discussed in rooftop solar under FiT for Sabah.

Sources and further reading

  1. German storage subsidy program to expire (6 November 2015), pv magazine
  2. End of German energy storage funding will see market growth fall to 13% in 2016 (24 November 2015), pv magazine
  3. Germany: Frustration over wait for new PV storage subsidy announcement (5 January 2016), pv magazine
  4. Germany's solar+storage subsidy extended to 2018 (22 February 2016), pv magazine
  5. Solar Cluster Baden-Württemberg begrüßt die Wiederaufnahme der Speicher-Förderung, Solarserver
  6. KfW meldet Zusage-Stopp für das Förderprogramm Erneuerbare Energien – Speicher, Solarserver
  7. Press release, 1 March 2016: KfW resumes promotion of battery storage systems, KfW