ASEAN Energy Awards 2012: the call for entries and the Diamond Building's win
How the 2012 ASEAN energy-efficient building competition worked, and why Putrajaya's Diamond Building, at a measured 65–72 kWh/m² a year, took the top prize.
In January 2013 SEDA Malaysia called for entries to the ASEAN RE Project Competition. What the off-grid, on-grid and cogeneration categories meant, and how 2013 turned out.
On 28 January 2013, the call went out in Malaysia for the ASEAN Renewable Energy Project Competition 2013. The Sustainable Energy Development Authority (SEDA Malaysia), as coordinator for the ASEAN Renewable Energy Sub-Sector Network, invited owners and managers of operating renewable energy projects to submit reports by 29 March 2013. The competition is one strand of the ASEAN Energy Awards organised by the ASEAN Centre for Energy (ACE), and it was open to biomass, biogas, solar, mini-hydro and other renewable projects.
Most renewable energy awards reward equipment. The ASEAN competition rewards projects that are already running, which means entrants have to show operating data: how much energy the plant actually delivered, how reliably, at what cost, and with what benefit to the people it serves. In early 2013 that suited Malaysia well. The feed-in tariff introduced under the Renewable Energy Act 2011 had brought a wave of new grid-connected projects, while rural electrification programmes in Sabah and Sarawak had produced a stock of off-grid hybrid and micro-hydro systems worth showcasing.
The 2013 competition grouped entries into three categories.
Off-grid projects supply electricity, and sometimes heat or mechanical power, to users who are not connected to a utility network. Typical ASEAN examples are solar-diesel hybrid systems for remote schools and villages, community micro-hydro schemes and biomass gasifiers on islands. Judges look closely at availability and maintenance, because an off-grid system that fails has no grid to fall back on, and at how the community or operator is organised to keep it running. Malaysia’s rural school programme is described in our article on hybrid solar power for rural schools, and a community example in micro-hydro for Kg Tiku.
On-grid projects export electricity into a utility network. In Malaysia in 2013 this meant mostly plants selling under the feed-in tariff: mini-hydro, biogas from palm oil mill effluent, landfill gas, biomass and solar PV. For these projects the key performance figure is energy delivered relative to capacity, usually expressed as capacity factor:
Capacity factor = annual energy exported (MWh) / (rated capacity (MW) × 8,760 h)
Worked example (hypothetical plant). A 5 MW mini-hydro station exporting 26,280 MWh in a year has a capacity factor of 26,280 / (5 × 8,760) = 26,280 / 43,800 = 0.60, or 60%. The same calculation for a rooftop PV system in Malaysia would give a much lower figure, because the sun shines for only part of each day; this is why capacity factors should be compared within a technology, not across technologies. The mechanics of selling solar electricity under the tariff are covered in generate electricity at home and earn.
Cogeneration, or combined heat and power, produces electricity and useful heat from the same fuel. In ASEAN the classic renewable case is a palm oil mill or sugar mill burning its own fibre and shell residues in a boiler, using the steam for a turbine and then for process heating. Because the heat would otherwise be wasted, overall efficiency is the measure that matters:
Overall efficiency = (electricity output + useful heat output) / fuel energy input
Worked example (hypothetical plant). A biomass boiler and turbine taking in 10 MW of fuel energy and delivering 2 MW of electricity and 5 MW of process steam has an overall efficiency of (2 + 5) / 10 = 70%, compared with 20% if the steam were simply condensed and its heat discarded.
Entrants submit a written report on their project. Because the competition is about operating plants, a convincing report rests on measured data rather than nameplate claims: metered energy output over at least a full year, downtime and its causes, the project’s costs and revenues, the fuel or resource used, and the environmental and social effects on the surrounding community. A modest project with a clean operating record and good documentation can make a stronger case than a novel one with patchy data.
At the 2012 awards in Phnom Penh, the Sungai Perting mini-hydro power station in Bentong, Pahang, won a renewable energy best-practice award for Malaysia, in the same year that the Energy Commission’s Diamond Building won the building prize described in our article on the ASEAN Energy Awards 2012.
The 2013 awards were presented on 25 September 2013 at the 31st ASEAN Ministers on Energy Meeting in Bali, Indonesia. The renewable energy competition attracted 18 entries from across the region. In the commercial on-grid category, the winner was a wind turbine project in Sathingphra District, Songkhla Province, Thailand, and the first runner-up was PETRONAS’s 685 kWp rooftop solar PV installation on the Suria KLCC shopping centre in Kuala Lumpur. That system covers a 9,000 m² roof, uses six different solar technologies to compare their performance in Malaysia’s climate, and was reported to supply about 30% of the mall’s energy needs.
The renewable energy project competition has remained part of the ASEAN Energy Awards in the years since, presented each year alongside the ministers’ meeting. Its premise has stayed the same: projects are recognised for what they have actually delivered in operation, which makes the winners’ reports a useful record of what works in the region’s conditions.