ASEAN Energy Awards 2013: the renewable energy project competition explained
In January 2013 SEDA Malaysia called for entries to the ASEAN RE Project Competition. What the off-grid, on-grid and cogeneration categories meant, and how 2013 turned out.
How the 2012 ASEAN energy-efficient building competition worked, and why Putrajaya's Diamond Building, at a measured 65–72 kWh/m² a year, took the top prize.
In April 2012 the Sustainable Energy Development Authority (SEDA Malaysia) invited owners and managers of Malaysian buildings and factories to enter the 2012 ASEAN Energy Awards. SEDA was acting as national coordinator for the ASEAN Centre for Energy (ACE), which runs the awards, and entries for the energy-efficient building and energy management competitions had to reach its Putrajaya secretariat by 11 April 2012. Five months later, a Malaysian government building won the top building prize.
The ASEAN Energy Awards are a regional recognition programme organised every year by ACE since 2000. They cover energy efficiency and renewable energy, and the winners are announced at a gala dinner held alongside the annual ASEAN Ministers on Energy Meeting (AMEM). Each member state runs its own national screening first, so the entries that reach the regional judges have already been through a domestic round. In Malaysia, SEDA handled that coordination in 2012.
In 2012 the programme had two strands relevant to buildings:
Entries were judged within categories rather than against every building in the region. The building categories used by ACE in this period were:
| Category | What it recognised |
|---|---|
| New and Existing Buildings | Buildings designed for efficiency from the outset; in 2012 limited to buildings no more than five years old |
| Retrofitted Buildings | Older buildings whose energy use was cut by later upgrades |
| Tropical Buildings | Designs that use climate-responsive strategies such as natural ventilation and daylight |
| Special Submission | Projects that did not fit the other categories |
The split matters for a tropical region. An air-conditioned office tower, a refurbished 1980s block and a naturally ventilated building face very different problems, and judging them separately rewards good engineering in each situation.
The headline number in most entries is the building energy intensity (BEI), the annual energy consumption per square metre of floor area:
BEI = annual energy consumption (kWh/year) / floor area (m²)
Malaysian practice normally excludes areas such as car parks from the floor area so that buildings can be compared fairly. A lower BEI is better. BEI is quoted at a stated number of operating hours, because an office used 12 hours a day will consume more than the same building used eight.
Worked example. A 10,000 m² office that used 2,100,000 kWh in a year would have a BEI of 2,100,000 / 10,000 = 210 kWh/m²/year. If the same floor area were served at 65 kWh/m²/year, annual consumption would be 650,000 kWh, a reduction of 1,450,000 kWh.
The 2012 awards were presented in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, during the gala dinner of the 30th AMEM on 12 September 2012. The Energy Commission’s headquarters in Putrajaya, known as the Diamond Building, won the top prize in the New and Existing Buildings category and was described in Malaysian reporting as the most energy-efficient building at that year’s awards.
The seven-storey building, which the Energy Commission’s staff occupied from June 2010, had already become the first Malaysian office to receive a Green Building Index Platinum rating and the first building outside Singapore to receive a Green Mark Platinum rating. The principal architect was Dr Soontorn Boonyatikarn, working with the local practice NR Architect, with IEN Consultants as sustainability consultant.
Its main features, as published by the Energy Commission and in contemporary reporting, were:
| Figure | BEI (kWh/m²/year) | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Typical Malaysian office | 210 | Energy Commission |
| Diamond Building design target (2,800 h/year) | 85 | Energy Commission |
| Reported in 2011, first year of operation | 72 | Energy Commission, quoted by The Star |
| Published average | 65 | Energy Commission |
Against the 210 kWh/m²/year reference, the design target works out to (210 − 85) / 210 ≈ 60% lower, and the published average of 65 to (210 − 65) / 210 ≈ 69% lower. The Energy Commission itself describes the design as a 65% reduction, so the exact percentage depends on the baseline and operating hours chosen. On any of these figures the building used roughly a third of the energy of a conventional office, which is the comparison its sustainability consultant gave when the award was announced.
Malaysian entries also won in other strands that year: a green data centre in energy-efficiency best practice, the Sungai Perting mini-hydro station in Bentong, Pahang, in renewable energy, and Universiti Teknologi Malaysia’s sustainable energy management programme in energy management. The renewable energy strand is covered in our article on the 2013 ASEAN RE project competition.
The Diamond Building showed that a low BEI in a hot, humid climate came mainly from passive design decisions made early, not from equipment added later. Solar PV supplied only about a tenth of its energy; shading, daylight and radiant cooling did most of the work. That lesson applies equally to the other regional landmark of the period, Singapore’s Supertree Grove and cooled conservatories. For readers sceptical of efficiency claims, measured BEI over several years is the figure to ask for, as our piece on so-called energy saving devices argues. The ASEAN Energy Awards have continued to be presented each year alongside the ministers’ meeting.