The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

What are sinkholes and how are they formed? Karst, cover-collapse and human triggers

How sinkholes form: dissolution of limestone, cover-subsidence and cover-collapse types, human triggers such as leaking pipes and pumping, and the 2010 Guatemala City collapse.

Line illustration for Malaysia Energy Archive

A sinkhole is a depression or hole in the ground that forms when material beneath the surface is removed, usually by water, so that the surface subsides or collapses into the void. The U.S. Geological Survey defines a sinkhole as an area of ground with no natural external surface drainage: water that falls there drains underground. In late July 2012 the Daily Express in Sabah ran an explainer graphic on how sinkholes form. At the time, the best-known recent example was the chasm that opened in Guatemala City in May 2010. This article explains the main types of sinkhole, why some form slowly and others suddenly, and how human activity can trigger them.

Karst: where natural sinkholes form

Most natural sinkholes occur in karst terrain, landscapes underlain by rocks that dissolve in water. The usual rocks are limestone and dolomite (carbonates), together with gypsum and salt (evaporites). Rainwater absorbs carbon dioxide from the air and soil, forming a weak carbonic acid. As it percolates along joints and bedding planes, it slowly dissolves carbonate rock:

CaCO3 + H2O + CO2  →  Ca(HCO3)2   (dissolved calcium bicarbonate)

Over thousands of years this widens cracks into conduits and caves. What happens at the surface depends mainly on what lies on top of the rock.

The three main types

The USGS distinguishes three main types.

1. Dissolution sinkholes. Where limestone is bare or thinly covered, rainfall and surface water dissolve the rock at the surface and along joints. The dissolved rock is carried away, and a shallow depression slowly forms. These develop gradually and rarely cause sudden damage.

2. Cover-subsidence sinkholes. Where the rock is covered by permeable, sandy sediment, grains trickle down into widening cavities below, a process called ravelling. The surface sags gradually into a bowl. Where the cover is thicker or more clayey, these features are smaller and can go unnoticed for a long time.

3. Cover-collapse sinkholes. Where the cover contains significant clay, it is cohesive enough to bridge over a growing void. Sediment is lost from below, forming a hidden cavity (a “soil arch”) that migrates upwards. When the arch finally becomes too thin to support itself, the surface fails abruptly, sometimes within hours. These are the dramatic, steep-sided holes that swallow roads and buildings. Over time, erosion softens them into shallower bowls.

Cross-sections comparing a cover-subsidence sinkhole, which sags gradually, with a cover-collapse sinkhole, where a void grows under clay until the surface fails Cover-subsidence (sandy cover) Cover-collapse (clay cover) sand ravels down limestone with conduit clay bridges void limestone with conduit surface fails here
Figure: In sandy cover the ground sags gradually. In clay cover a void grows unseen until the roof collapses.

Human triggers

Sinkholes are not only natural. The USGS lists several ways human activity can trigger or speed up collapse, especially in karst.

  • Groundwater pumping. Lowering the water table removes buoyant support from sediments over cavities, and can start ravelling.
  • Changes to drainage. Diverting or concentrating surface water, for example through new drainage systems, storm-water ponds or paving, can send large flows into vulnerable ground.
  • Surface loading. New structures, fill or water-storage ponds add weight over cavities.
  • Construction and dewatering. Excavation, piling and site dewatering disturb the cover and the flow of groundwater.

Outside karst, the most common urban cause is leaking or broken pipes. Water escaping from sewers, storm drains or water mains washes fine soil into the pipe or away along its bedding, a process known as internal erosion or piping. A void forms beneath the road surface, which can stay intact until the void is large, then fail suddenly. Many urban road collapses reported in Malaysia and elsewhere are of this kind.

The Guatemala City collapse, 2010

The Guatemala City chasm opened in late May 2010, in the heavy rain of Tropical Storm Agatha. National Geographic described it as about 18 m wide and about 100 m deep, roughly 30 storeys. It swallowed a three-storey building. It was widely called a sinkhole, but Guatemala City has no limestone at that depth. It is built on thick deposits of loose volcanic pumice. Geologist Sam Bonis argued that it was better described as a piping feature. A leaking or burst sewer or storm drain had probably hollowed out a cavity in the easily eroded pumice over a long period, and the storm’s rain triggered the final collapse. A similar hole had opened nearby in 2007, and a report co-written by Bonis had warned that more would follow unless the sewer system was inspected.

The Guatemala case is a reminder that the most dangerous “sinkholes” in cities are often failures of buried infrastructure rather than of the rock.

What this means for engineers in Malaysia

Malaysia has real karst hazards. Limestone underlies parts of the Kinta Valley in Perak and parts of the Klang Valley, and sinkhole incidents in the Kinta Valley are well documented. In those areas, site investigation for foundations routinely includes probing for cavities. For most urban areas, including Sabah’s towns, the practical lessons are the same as Guatemala’s:

  1. Maintain and inspect sewer and drainage pipes, especially old ones.
  2. Investigate new depressions, cracks or unexplained water loss promptly.
  3. Control drainage and dewatering during construction.
  4. Treat sudden settlement after heavy rain as a warning sign rather than routine potholing.

Related engineering topics on this site include lightning and surge protection and cable current ratings. Both are reminders that buried and exposed infrastructure needs design margins and inspection.

What has changed since

The physics is unchanged since 2012. What has changed is monitoring. Satellite radar interferometry (InSAR) and ground-penetrating radar are increasingly used to detect slow ground movement and voids before they collapse. Ageing sewer and drainage networks remain a leading cause of urban sinkholes in many countries.

Sources and further reading

  1. Sinkholes, U.S. Geological Survey, Water Science School
  2. Guatemala sinkhole created by humans, not nature, National Geographic
  3. 2010 Guatemala City sinkhole, Wikipedia
  4. An overview of sinkhole geohazard incidence recorded in the Kinta Valley area, Perak, Universiti Malaysia Sabah / UTM library record