The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

The right-to-repair movement and sustainable personal transport

How the EU repair directive, the Batteries Regulation and US state laws treat e-bikes, e-scooters and motorcycles, where parts pairing fits, and why safety and warranties complicate repair.

Line illustration for Sustainable Mobility

E-bikes, e-scooters and electric motorcycles are as much battery-and-software products as they are machines. That makes them more efficient than cars, but it also means their working life can be cut short by a sealed battery, an unavailable part or a diagnostic tool only a franchised dealer may use. The right-to-repair movement, which began with cars and phones, is now reaching personal transport. This article sets out what the main laws actually require, where they stop, and why safety and warranty concerns make the debate harder than it looks.

Why repair rules matter for personal transport

The environmental case is straightforward. Most of the footprint of a small electric vehicle is fixed at the factory, so every extra year of use dilutes it. Our lifecycle analysis of electric and petrol motorcycles shows how strongly lifetime distance drives the per-kilometre result, and the companion piece on why repairing an e-bike can beat replacing it makes the same point at the scale of a single bicycle.

What ends a vehicle’s life is rarely the frame. It is more often a battery that cannot be opened, a motor that cannot be sourced, or electronics that refuse a replacement part. Repair law targets exactly those choke points.

The European Union: the repair directive

Directive (EU) 2024/1799, adopted on 13 June 2024 and published on 10 July 2024, is the EU’s general “right to repair” law. Member States had to transpose it by 31 July 2026.

Its core obligation, in Article 5, requires manufacturers to repair goods at the consumer’s request, free of charge or at a reasonable price and within a reasonable time. Crucially, the obligation only covers products listed in Annex II, which are those already subject to repairability requirements under other EU laws. Annex II currently lists ten product groups, mostly household appliances, displays, servers, phones and tablets. The tenth entry is the one that matters here: “goods incorporating light means of transport batteries”, linked to the Batteries Regulation. In practice that brings many e-bikes and e-scooters into scope.

For those products the directive also:

  • forbids manufacturers from using contractual clauses, hardware or software techniques that impede repair, unless justified by legitimate and objective factors such as intellectual property protection (Article 5(6));
  • stops manufacturers impeding independent repairers from using original, second-hand, compatible or 3D-printed spare parts that comply with the law;
  • requires spare parts and tools to be offered at a reasonable price that does not deter repair (Article 5(4)).

Other provisions apply more broadly. Where a consumer chooses repair under the legal guarantee, the guarantee period is extended once by 12 months, for sales contracts concluded on or after 31 July 2026. Repairers may offer a standardised European Repair Information Form, though it is voluntary. A European online platform to find repairers must be running by 31 July 2027. Each Member State must also adopt at least one measure to promote repair; the recitals suggest repair vouchers, repair funds, training programmes, support for community repair initiatives and tax measures.

The EU Batteries Regulation: replaceable LMT batteries

Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 goes further for the component that most often decides whether an e-bike lives or dies. It defines a light means of transport (LMT) battery as a sealed battery of 25 kg or less designed to power wheeled vehicles driven by an electric motor alone or with human power, including category L vehicles.

Provision Requirement Applies from
Article 11(5) LMT batteries, and the individual cells in the pack, must be readily removable and replaceable by an independent professional throughout the product’s life 18 February 2027
Article 11(6) “Readily replaceable” means a compatible battery can be fitted without affecting function, performance or safety 18 February 2027
Article 11(7) Batteries must be available as spare parts for at least five years after the last unit of a model is placed on the market, at a reasonable, non-discriminatory price 18 February 2027
Article 11(8) Software must not be used to impede replacement of a battery or its key components with a compatible one 18 February 2027
Article 77 Every LMT battery placed on the market must have a digital battery passport 18 February 2027
Article 60 Waste LMT battery collection targets of 51% by end-2028 and 61% by end-2031 As stated

Two details are worth noting. First, replaceability is by an independent professional, not the rider: the law accepts that opening a traction battery needs skill and equipment. Second, the cell-level requirement is unusual and significant, because a pack with one failed cell group no longer has to be scrapped by design. We checked the consolidated text dated 13 August 2026; these dates were unchanged in that version.

The United States: a patchwork with gaps

As far as we could verify, the US has no federal right-to-repair law in force for vehicles. State laws differ widely, and their definitions often exclude exactly the vehicles discussed here.

Law What it covers Personal transport position
Massachusetts, Acts of 2013 ch. 165 Diagnostic and repair information for motor vehicles; from model year 2018, access through a standard interface such as SAE J2534 Motorcycles are expressly excluded from the definition of “motor vehicle”
Massachusetts 2020 ballot Question 1 Extended access to telematics (“mechanical data”); approved by about 75% of voters Builds on the 2013 law and its definitions
New York General Business Law § 399-nn Digital electronic equipment first made and sold in New York on or after 1 July 2023 Excludes motor vehicle makers and expressly excludes electric bicycle manufacturers, distributors, retailers and dealers
Colorado HB22-1031 Powered wheelchairs, effective 1 January 2023 First of Colorado’s sector-specific repair laws
Colorado HB24-1121 Digital electronic equipment, from 1 January 2026, with limits on parts pairing for equipment first sold after that date Exempts motor vehicles; the official summary does not mention e-bikes, so their status should be checked case by case

The pattern is clear. The car laws excluded motorcycles, the consumer electronics laws excluded vehicles, and at least one excluded e-bikes by name. Micromobility has largely fallen between the two.

Parts pairing and software locks

“Parts pairing” means a component is cryptographically or digitally tied to a specific vehicle, so a replacement only works once authorised software registers it. On e-bikes this can apply to motors, batteries, displays and controllers.

There are legitimate reasons for it. Pairing supports anti-theft functions, prevents incompatible batteries from being connected to a motor controller, and lets manufacturers track safety recalls. The problem comes when the only software able to authorise a part is restricted to franchised dealers. Bosch, for example, describes its DiagnosticTool as used by specialist dealers to read out eBike information, install updates and make adjustments; owners and unaffiliated workshops depend on that dealer network for those functions.

Legislators are drawing lines around the practice rather than banning it outright. Colorado’s 2024 law prohibits parts pairing that prevents an owner or independent repairer from installing a replacement part, reduces performance, or triggers misleading warnings, while still allowing pairing for recording repair information and for biometric security components. The EU Batteries Regulation’s Article 11(8) applies the same idea narrowly to batteries.

Safety and warranty tensions

Right to repair is not a free-for-all, and honest advocates acknowledge that. Lithium-ion traction batteries store a great deal of energy, and poor repairs can start fires.

  • Certification. New York City’s Local Law 39, in force since 16 September 2023, bars the sale, lease or rental of e-bikes, e-scooters and their batteries unless certified to UL 2849 (e-bikes), UL 2272 (other devices) or UL 2271 (batteries). It covers second-hand sales and rentals too.
  • Reconditioned packs. The same March 2023 New York City package restricted the assembly and reconditioning of lithium-ion batteries using cells taken from used batteries, and their commercial sale.
  • EU caution. The Batteries Regulation itself anticipates later rules on the safety of repaired LMT batteries, which is why it places cell replacement in professional hands.
  • Warranty. Manufacturers commonly attach conditions to their own warranties about who may open a product. The EU directive changes the balance for Annex II goods by banning repair-impeding techniques, but its text does not settle every warranty dispute that can follow a faulty third-party repair.

The workable middle ground is professional, documented repair using compatible certified parts, with manufacturers supplying the information and tools to do it.

What this means for owners, buyers and repairers

Before buying an e-bike or e-scooter, ask:

  1. Can the battery be removed, and is a replacement listed as a spare part?
  2. Can an independent workshop read fault codes, or only a franchised dealer?
  3. Are motor, controller and display paired to the frame, and who can re-register a replacement?
  4. Are the battery, charger and vehicle certified to a recognised standard?
  5. Are service manuals or exploded parts diagrams published?

For repairers: keep records of parts origin and certification, decline cell-level work without proper equipment and training, and know which jurisdictions’ rules apply to the products you service.

Outside the EU and US: many products sold in the Gulf and Southeast Asia are designed for European markets, so EU design rules such as the 2027 battery replaceability requirement may well shape what reaches local showrooms even where no equivalent local law exists. Owners should not assume that, however, and should check the product itself. Local battery handling is covered in our guide to battery recycling and safe disposal, and the wider economics in the role of independent repair in the circular economy.

Limitations

This article summarises legal texts and official summaries; it is not legal advice. National transposition of the EU directive may add detail not covered here. US state laws change frequently, and we did not review every state. We could not verify how individual e-bike manufacturers will implement the 2027 battery rules, or whether Colorado’s law reaches e-bikes in practice, so those points are left open.

Sources and further reading

  1. Directive (EU) 2024/1799 on common rules promoting the repair of goods, EUR-Lex
  2. Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 concerning batteries and waste batteries (consolidated text, 13 August 2026), EUR-Lex
  3. An Act Relative to Automotive Repair, Acts of 2013, Chapter 165, Commonwealth of Massachusetts
  4. New York General Business Law § 399-nn (Digital Fair Repair Act), New York State Senate
  5. HB24-1121 Consumer Right to Repair Digital Electronic Equipment, Colorado General Assembly
  6. City reminds retailers and consumers to only purchase certified lithium-ion batteries and mobility devices (Local Law 39), NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, 8 September 2023
  7. NYC lithium-ion battery safety package signed into law, Bicycle Retailer and Industry News, 21 March 2023
  8. Bosch eBike Systems: dealer service and DiagnosticTool, Bosch eBike Systems

Disclosure: The Green Mechanics is published by owners who also operate a micromobility repair business in the UAE. This article contains no commercial links and follows our editorial policy. About our ownership.