The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

Teck Guan launches cellulosic bio-ethanol pilot project in Tawau, Sabah

In June 2013 Sabah planter Teck Guan began a pilot plant in Tawau to make ethanol from palm empty fruit bunches. How cellulosic ethanol works, the reported yield and what followed.

Line illustration for Renewable Energy

In June 2013, Syarikat Teck Guan Group, a Tawau-based plantation and commodities company, announced that it had begun a pilot plant to produce lignocellulosic bio-ethanol from oil palm biomass. Bernama reported that construction had started in May and that the plant was expected to be running by the end of that month. It was described as the first plant in Malaysia to make ethanol from empty fruit bunches (EFB), the fibrous stalks left after palm fruit is stripped at the mill.

The announcement

Teck Guan’s director of operational innovation and R&D, Douglas Furtek, told Bernama that the plant could produce 72 litres of ethanol from a tonne of wet EFB, and that capacity could readily be scaled up. He said he hoped the project would attract more foreign investment to Sabah, Malaysia’s largest palm oil producing state. The ethanol was seen as a platform not only for fuel but for bio-based chemicals and bioplastics.

Agensi Inovasi Malaysia (AIM), the government innovation agency behind the National Biomass Strategy 2020, argued at the time that Sabah was unusually well placed: it has large volumes of palm biomass and many mills within a relatively compact area, which keeps collection costs down. The strategy projected that making higher-value products from palm biomass could add about RM30 billion to gross national income and create some 66,000 jobs by 2020.

Teck Guan did not publish a plant capacity or investment figure at launch. In a later interview, the company described the pilot as using a plant design from Mitsui Engineering and Shipbuilding with Inbicon’s pretreatment technology.

Why empty fruit bunches?

Palm oil mills generate EFB in large quantities. Traditionally it was burnt, dumped or returned to the plantation as mulch. Unlike first-generation ethanol, which ferments sugar or starch from food crops, cellulosic ethanol uses the structural material of plants, so it does not compete with food and turns a waste stream into a product.

The difficulty is that this material is designed by nature to resist breakdown. Plant cell walls are made of:

  • cellulose, long chains of glucose packed into tough crystalline fibres;
  • hemicellulose, a branched polymer of mixed sugars, including five-carbon sugars such as xylose;
  • lignin, a non-sugar polymer that binds the structure together and shields the sugars.

How a cellulosic ethanol plant works

  1. Pretreatment. The shredded biomass is treated with heat, steam and pressure, sometimes with dilute acid or other chemicals, to open up the lignin-hemicellulose structure so that enzymes can reach the cellulose.
  2. Enzymatic hydrolysis. Cellulase enzymes break cellulose into glucose; hemicellulose yields a mix of sugars.
  3. Fermentation. Yeast or engineered microbes convert the sugars into ethanol. Fermenting the five-carbon sugars efficiently was a major research challenge in 2013.
  4. Distillation and dehydration. The dilute “beer” is distilled and dried to fuel-grade ethanol.
  5. Residue use. The lignin-rich solids can be burnt in a boiler to supply the process with steam and power.

A rough yield check

How does 72 litres per wet tonne compare with what is chemically possible? The composition figures below are illustrative assumptions, not Teck Guan data:

Wet EFB: 1,000 kg, assume 60% moisture  →  400 kg dry matter
Assume cellulose = 40% of dry matter     →  160 kg cellulose
Glucose from cellulose: × 1.11           →  178 kg glucose
Theoretical ethanol: × 0.511             →  91 kg ethanol
Volume at 0.789 kg/L                     →  about 115 L

On those assumptions, the cellulose fraction alone could in theory yield about 115 litres per wet tonne, so 72 litres would be roughly 60% of the cellulose-only theoretical maximum, a reasonable figure for a first pilot. Converting the hemicellulose sugars as well would raise the ceiling. The calculation also shows why moisture matters: much of what a mill delivers as “a tonne of EFB” is water.

Why it mattered in 2013

The Tawau pilot came during a period of intense interest in second-generation biofuels worldwide and in Malaysia’s plans to move up the palm oil value chain. Malaysia was also expanding palm biodiesel blending at the time (see our article on the B10 biodiesel programme). Cellulosic ethanol offered a way to earn revenue from biomass rather than from more crude palm oil. For a more fundamental approach to making fuels from sunlight, see our explainer on artificial photosynthesis.

What has changed since

  • In the later interview with Advanced BioFuels USA, Teck Guan’s R&D director said the company had not committed to commercial-scale production, citing low ethanol prices and the absence of a bio-ethanol blending mandate in Malaysia. No public announcement of a commercial EFB-to-ethanol plant by Teck Guan has been found.
  • Globally, cellulosic ethanol proved harder to commercialise than expected in the 2010s: several first commercial plants in the United States and Europe were closed or sold after struggling with costs and reliability. Malaysia’s biofuel policy has continued to centre on palm biodiesel blending rather than ethanol.
  • Oil palm biomass remains an important resource in Sabah, used increasingly for boiler fuel, biomass power, pellets and compost.

Sources and further reading

  1. Teck Guan launches bio-ethanol project in Tawau, The Star / Bernama (12 June 2013)
  2. National Biomass Strategy 2020: New wealth creation for Malaysia's biomass industry (version 2.0, 2013), Agensi Inovasi Malaysia (via FAOLEX)
  3. 4 Minutes with Douglas Furtek, Director, Operational Innovation, R&D, Teck Guan Group, Advanced BioFuels USA
  4. Deconstruction and fractionation (biochemical conversion of biomass), US Department of Energy, Bioenergy Technologies Office