The Green MechanicsEnergy, engineering and sustainable mobility

Atkinson Clock Tower to stay: the 2011 decision and the history of Kota Kinabalu's 1905 landmark

In December 2011 Sabah's Central Board rejected a commercial project beside Kota Kinabalu's Atkinson Clock Tower. The tower's 1905 history, heritage status and later debates.

Line illustration for Malaysia Energy Archive

In December 2011 the director of Sabah’s Town and Regional Planning Department, Mursidi Sapie, said that the state’s Central Board had rejected a proposed multi-storey commercial project on land next to the Atkinson Clock Tower in Kota Kinabalu. Heritage campaigners welcomed the decision. They also pointed out that the developers could still appeal once they met environmental-impact and heritage conditions. The tower is among the oldest surviving structures in the city and one of Sabah’s best-known landmarks. This article explains the 2011 decision and the history behind it.

The tower

Item Detail
Location A bluff on Signal Hill Road, above central Kota Kinabalu
Completed 1905 (the clock began working on 19 April 1905)
Named after Francis George Atkinson, first District Officer of Jesselton
Height about 15 m (50 ft)
Original material timber (mirabau)
Clock maker William Potts & Sons, Leeds

Francis George Atkinson died of malaria, then known as “Borneo fever”, in December 1902, aged 28. His mother, Mary Edith Atkinson, presented a two-faced clock to the town in his memory. A tower to house it was built with money raised by friends and the community.

Standing high above what was then a small port, the tower served for decades as a landmark for ships approaching Jesselton, a role it kept into the 1950s. It survived the Second World War, though Japanese machine-gun fire damaged the dial and mechanism. A local watch dealer repaired the clock and has maintained it since. The tower was extensively renovated in 1959 for the town’s diamond jubilee, and the clock faces were replaced in 1961.

Heritage status

The site was gazetted in 1983. The tower is protected under Sabah’s Antiquities and Treasure Trove Enactment 1977 and the Cultural Heritage Enactment 1997. Protection of the structure itself, however, did not automatically control what could be built around it. That gap was at the heart of the 2010–2011 controversy.

The 2010–2011 controversy

The disputed project was a commercial building of about 16 storeys, proposed as a joint venture between the Sabah Housing and Town Development Authority (SHTDA, known by its Malay initials LPPB), which owned the land, and a private developer. The site lay below the tower, close to Padang Merdeka. Heritage groups, residents and NGOs objected that a tall building there would overshadow the tower, block the historic sight lines between the hill, the town and the sea, and set a precedent for the surrounding green space.

In October 2010 the state’s Local Government and Housing Minister, Datuk Hajiji Noor, said the Central Board had met but was waiting for a revised building design. He said the state Cabinet would have the final say, and assured the public that the tower itself would be preserved. Campaigners also challenged the approval process in court in 2011.

In December 2011 the planning director confirmed that the Central Board had rejected the project. Heritage Sabah, a campaign group, welcomed the decision. It warned that the right of appeal left the outcome open, and asked who would consider an appeal. At a state planning-standards workshop held that month, the group called for heritage sites and their surroundings to be written into planning policy, mapped on plans and protected by buffer controls.

Why the decision mattered

  • Setting, not just structure. The case established in public debate that protecting a monument means protecting its setting: views, open space and scale.
  • Planning process. It highlighted the role of Sabah’s Central Board, the state-level planning authority, and the question of how local plans should treat heritage zones.
  • Civil society. Sustained campaigning by NGOs and residents influenced a major planning outcome in Kota Kinabalu.

For another example of how a disused heritage building in central Kota Kinabalu found a new public role, see Kota Kinabalu’s street-art ruin. The city’s coastline is described in Sunset at Sutera Harbour.

What has changed since

The issue did not end in 2011. In 2017 Kota Kinabalu City Hall was reported to have revived plans for the shelved complex, and a suggestion to relocate the tower drew strong objections from activists and the architectural profession. In February 2018 the tower was among the sites gazetted under Sabah’s State Heritage Enactment 2017. A 2021 landscape proposal for the area again drew public scrutiny. The tower remains on its original site.

Sources and further reading

  1. No decision on project at clock tower yet, The Borneo Post
  2. Battle to save Atkinson clock tower not over (16 December 2011), The Borneo Post
  3. Atkinson Clock Tower, Wikipedia
  4. Activists slam KK City Hall for reviving shelved project, The Star